We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By continuing to browse this website, you agree to our use of cookies. For more information, please refer to our privacy policy.

The Creative Effectiveness Playbook

The 9 keys to crafting advertising that drives profitable brand growth.
Thank you for subscribing!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form. Please try again.

Sign up to our effectiveness newsletter

What’s the secret formula for advertising success?

It’s a debate as old as advertising itself and one that continues to spark passionate discussions to this day: What truly makes for an effective ad? While what’s ‘in’ today in the advertising world is often ‘out’ tomorrow, the fundamental pillars for success remain as relevant as ever.

Over more recent times some marketing experts have attempted to separate advertising’s role as a catalyst for short-term sales (‘activation’) and long-term brand growth (‘fame’), but our experience has shown that the very best advertising can and does deliver on both. Prioritizing one over the other is often a false dichotomy that only leads to wastage.

Adopting a robust methodology grounded in the wealth of empirical evidence available is therefore critical. And few have had a greater impact than Professor Byron Sharp of the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute and his seminal publication, How Brands Grow. At its core, advertising is about one thing: building mental availability. This forms the backbone of Cubery’s 3Cs Framework, with advertising that Captivates, Connects, and Compels fueling profitable brand growth.

But what specific tools and strategies do marketers have available at their disposal for achieving this? Well, after testing thousands upon thousands of ads across the globe over the last decade, we’ve distilled this wealth of learnings into 9 core building blocks for success. Through incorporating these learnings while undertaking creative development advertising has the best chance of landing with the ultimate arbiter of creativity—the consumer.

12 Advertising Success Factors - Cubery Market Research
Cubery - Creative Effectiveness - Characters
Characters

Develop stories which focus on a central protagonist people either love, or love to hate. Make them feel warm and relatable. Antagonists can help bring the audience onto your side.

You might also be interested in our deep-dive on Animals.
Cubery - Creative Effectiveness - Emotion
Emotion

Prioritize leaving an emotional impression over conveying product messages. Make people laugh or cry. Show how product benefits ladder up to emotional rewards. Memorability relies on making people feel something.

You might also be interested in our deep-dive on Humor.
Cubery - Creative Effectiveness - Storytelling
STORYTELLING

Focus on conveying only one key message, impression, or idea. The more you try to communicate, the more take-out of everything will be diluted (and you’ll also risk causing confusion).

Cubery - Creative Effectiveness - Peak-end Rule
Peak-end-rule

The right soundtrack can alter the entire dynamic of an ad. Amplify emotion by lessening the reliance on product-focused voiceovers/dialogue.

Cubery - Creative Effectiveness - Music
Music/Voiceover

Leverage the brand’s distinctive assets (colors, characters, storylines, slogans, jingles, etc.) and redeploy them in fresh and topical ways over time.

Cubery - Creative Effectiveness - Single-minded
Single Minded

Tell a great story. Take people through twists and turns. Use negative emotions to enhance the impact of an eventual positive resolve. Think of advertising as sponsored entertainment.

You might also be interested in our deep-dive on Universal Human Truths.
Cubery - Creative Effectiveness - Brand Assets
Brand Assets

Ensure the narrative and message is understood. Give the brand a clear role — both within the story and in facilitating outcomes (i.e. conveying intended messaging).

Cubery - Creative Effectiveness - Consistency
Consistency

In the absence of distinctive assets, use the brand to drive the narrative. Feature it during peak emotional moments and present it as the solution to the problem.

You might also be interested in our deep-dive on Peak-End Rule.
Cubery - Creative Effectiveness - Brand Hero
Brand Hero

In order to strengthen and reinforce brand memories, advertising needs to be consistently distinctive. Resist the urge to change. Balance freshness and familiarity.